Bratz juror dismissed, MGA seeks mistrial
July 26 12:05:01 PM, Yahoo News
Reuters - A juror in the copyright infringement trial over Bratz dolls was dismissed on Friday for making an ethnic slur against MGA Entertainment Inc Chief Executive Isaac Larian, causing MGA to seek a mistrial and casting doubt on the outcome of the case brought by Mattel Inc .
Mattel had prevailed in the first phase of trial, winning the rights to dozens of original Bratz drawings and sculpts, and was seeking damages of more than $1 billion.
U.S. District Judge Stephen Larson dismissed the female juror from the federal case in Riverside, California after another panelist complained about remarks she had made during deliberations over the drawings about Larian, an Iranian Jew who immigrated to the United States as a teenager.
Larson suspended the proceedings and set an August 4 hearing to determine whether the case should continue or end in a mistrial.
MGA attorney Thomas Nolan said the female juror told the rest of the 10-member panel during deliberations over which company owns the drawings that her husband, an attorney, had "a number of Iranian clients and they are stubborn and are known to be thieves."
Larian, who has attended nearly every day of the two-month trial, broke down after hearing about the comment, Nolan said.
"I moved today for a mistrial arguing that Mr Larian and MGA are entitled in the federal system to a unanimous verdict of all jurors and that all jurors must be impartial and not have hidden prejudices," Nolan said.
Mattel said in a statement that it found "this development to be very unfortunate."
"This trial, however, has been and will continue to be about Mr Larian's and MGA's wrongful behavior. Nothing changes that," the statement said.
Mattel won a near total victory over MGA in the first phase of the trial when the jury last week validated its claims to most of the concept drawings and models upon which the designs for the first four Bratz dolls were based.
The jury found that Bratz creator Carter Bryant made most of the drawings and models at issue while he was under contract to Mattel as a Barbie designer, and that MGA obtained them illegally.
This week, the panel was hearing evidence about whether the Bratz dolls and accessories made and sold by MGA since 2001 violate Mattel's copyright on the drawings and sculpts.
Mattel was seeking more than $1 billion in damages in connection with the alleged infringement.
Shares of Mattel fell 3.9 percent, or 81 cents, on Friday to $20.00 in after-hours trade.
(Reporting by Gina Keating, editing by Leslie Gevirtz)
Related articles
- Dow posts biggest one-day point gain in history
The huge rally comes after central banks worldwide pledge a variety of steps to prop up the global banking system.
… - Wall Street rescue to include Treasury stakes in healthy banks
The Bush administration is expected Tuesday to announce a broad plan to rescue frozen credit markets that includes buying stakes in financial institutions and insuring some bank debt for three years, according… - GM to close stamping plant near Grand Rapids
General Motors Corp.'s efforts to hoard cash and
outlast a prolonged economic slump claimed the jobs of more than
2,700 workers Monday as the automaker announced the demise of
factories in Michigan… - Mortgage crisis has turned homeownership upside down
Homeowners drowning in mortgage debt
Joey Goldner always approached real estate with a gardener's zeal. He'd… - Mitsubishi closes $9 billion investment in Morgan Stanley
NEW YORK -- Morgan Stanley completed a deal Monday to receive a $9 billion investment from Japanese bank Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group Inc., giving it a much-needed cash infusion.
- Major airlines slashing fuel surcharges
For the first time since oil prices began their meteoric rise this year, airlines are slashing fuel surcharges on a major international route: most flights between the U.S. and Europe.
- Wirtz buys out Glazer after 3 months in joint venture
Wirtz Beverage Group said Monday it has purchased Glazer's Distributors' interest in their newly-minted Illinois joint venture, just three months after the state's second- and third-largest liquor distributors… - Moody's lowers Walgreen debt rating a notch
Moody's Investors Services said Monday that it has lowered its rating on Walgreen Co.'s senior unsecured debt from A1 to A2.
- Chicago's Ennis Knupp to advise on bailout
The U.S. Treasury hired Chicago- based Ennis Knupp & Associates on a one-year, $2.5 million contract to provide advisory services on a government plan to restore confidence in credit markets.
- Treasury, Fed to meet on financial initiative
Reuters - The U.S. Treasury and Federal Reserve are meeting on Monday with "leading financial market participants" to finalize details on a market stabilization initiative, a Treasury spokeswoman said. - Dow jumps 400 in opening minutes
Wall Street snapped back Monday from last week's devastating losses after major governments announced further steps to support the global banking system, including plans by the U.S. Treasury to buy stocks… - Stock prices soar as governments pledge bank aid
The Dow Jones industrial average jumps almost 500 points, following rallies in foreign markets overnight.
… - Sears CFO to step down
Sears Holdings Corp. disclosed Monday that Miles Reidy intends to step down as Chief Financial Officer before year-end in order to "attend to a family issue," and will be succeeded by Michael D. Collins… - Morgan Stanley-MUFG deal closes, Morgan shares soar
Reuters - Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group Inc (MUFG) completed its purchase of a stake in Morgan Stanley on Monday with U.S. government support, helping close a deal that investors had feared would fall… - Calamos assets under management decline
Calamos Asset Management Inc. said Monday that assets under management as of Sept. 30 stood at $33.3 billion -- down 15 percent from $39.3 billion as of Aug. 31, and 29 percent lower than the $46.7 billion… - Morgan Stanley completes crucial deal with Mitsubishi UFJ
Morgan Stanley says Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group has completed its $9 billion investment in the firm, giving it a much-needed capital infusion.
- The Benefits Of Dollar-Cost Averaging
Investor's Business Daily - When autos go on sale, more people tend to want to buy. The same with clothing and TV sets and soft drinks. - Paul Krugman wins Nobel economics prize
The Princeton scholar and New York Times columnist is honored for formulating a new theory to answer questions about free trade.
… - Asian, EU markets higher amid global aid effort
Most Asian stock markets recovered Monday after last week's historic sell-off as governments in Europe and beyond intensified efforts to stabilize the world's troubled financial system.
- Key U.S. official sketches first steps of Wall Street rescue plan
Neel Kashkari says several programs have been set up to implement the plan, but he doesn't give a start time for the purchase of troubled assets. He says three firms are in the running to be the Treas
… - Stocks: Bargain prices or traps?
When the stock market goes on sale, smart investors are supposed to seize the opportunity.
- Sovereign confirms deal talks with Banco Santander
NEW YORK -- Sovereign Bancorp says it is in advanced discussions with Spain's Banco Santander regarding a possible buyout of the Philadelphia-based thrift.
- GM to close Janesville, Wis., plant in December
The U.S. automotive sales slump worked its way to
Janesville, Wis., Monday when General Motors Corp. told workers
that it would cease operations at a sport utility vehicle factory
there in December.
… - London shares leap more than 4.84%
AFP - The FTSE 100 soared on Monday, with the index of leading shares up 4.84 percent after leading banks accepted billions of pounds of taxpayers' money to prop up their ailing institutions.