• Politics
• Entertainment
• Business
• Tech

Review: Pass on `NCAA Football 09: All-Play'

July 25 06:05:01 AM, Yahoo News

AP - If the Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3 versions of "NCAA Football 09" are the starting seniors, then Wii owners might feel like redshirt freshmen with EA Sports' first college football game for Nintendo's popular gaming console.

"NCAA Football 09: All-Play" ($49.99, Wii) marks EA Sports' debut of its new "All-Play" lineup, five Wii-specific sports games looking to bring more casual gamers into the mix.

The game offers a friendly, laid-back presentation, arcade-style gameplay and a simplified "All-Play" control scheme that lets novice players simply shake their remotes to punt, pass and kick.

But the Wii-specific version disappoints with a complete lack of online play and graphics that are simply too inferior to the Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3 versions.

Any thoughts that "NCAA Football 09: All-Play" could be classified as a sports sim are quickly quashed by the main menu, which offers "Mascot game" as the top choice. Sure, playing 11 Albert the Alligators versus a team of Sparty the Spartans might be cute, but it's a feature better suited for a hidden cheat code than a game's primary option.

A better choice is "Play now," which can default to your favorite college team playing at home against an archrival.

The next step is to choose how much you want to control.

The simplest option is to use only the Wii remote, letting the game guide player movement while the player simply gives the remote a quick shake for throws, tackles or jukes. The problem is you don't really feel like you're impacting gameplay much.

For slightly more control, players can add the nunchuk and use its control stick for player movement while continuing with the shakes, but the contextual automation sometimes misses your intentions.

On one play I decided to run the option, a popular college play in which the quarterback rolls out either left and right and can choose to keep the ball or lateral to his running back.

In my mind I decided to keep the ball and attempt to juke past the approaching tackler, but the game interpreted the remote shake as my decision to toss the pigskin to my running back, resulting in a drive-killing fumble.

Standard control is similar to the more intuitive "Madden" scheme, and it's the best choice for experienced players and possibly many beginners. Gameplay can be fast-paced and fun with this option.

Touchdowns invite the scoring player to drum their remote and nunchuk to pump up the crowd, but these end-zone celebrations grow old quickly. Fortunately, this gimmick and the arcade-style trails on the football can be turned off.

"NCAA Football 09: All-Play" features team-specific fight songs and cheers, but stadiums seem to be missing the little touches that make you feel at home. I expected to see "This is ... The Swamp" in the corner of Florida Field, but it wasn't there.

What's really surprising is the game's emptiness on the sidelines, which were inhabited only by the chain gang — no benches, players, photographers or sounds guys. For comparison, I fired up last year's "Madden 08," and there they were.

I'm all for bringing more people into gaming, but companies wanting to broaden their reach must be careful not to alienate those of us who like sports games and have made the Wii their console of choice.

This game simply doesn't offer enough for that crowd.

___

Two out of four stars.

Related articles

• Microsoft set to release Silverlight 2
  InfoWorld - Microsoft's Silverlight 2 browser plug-in technology for rich Internet applications will be generally available on Tuesday along with supportive development tools, the company said during a…
• Vaunted Michelin guide adds mobile Internet to its review menu
  AFP - Michelin guides, lauded as roadmaps to the world's finest cuisine, will be delivered to iPhones and other "smart" mobile devices as the century-old publication embraces the Internet age.
• New service to stop loose lips from crashing cars
  AP - When David Teater's 12-year-old son, Joe, was killed in 2004 by a driver who was talking on a cell phone, he tried to cut back on his own habit of driving and talking. It turned out to be very difficult.
• Bush signs RIAA-backed intellectual-property law
  CNET - Updated at 12:45 p.m. PDT with quotes.
• Sony Says PS3 Price Will Remain Firm for Holidays
  NewsFactor - The Tokyo Game Show is, to put it mildly, a noisy event as game manufacturers crank up the volume on their latest racing or military combat products. But the loudest sound may have come from…
• Huge Credit Fraud Ring Sends Europeans' Data To Pakistan
  marshotel excerpts from a story at the Wall Street Journal: "European law-enforcement officials uncovered a highly sophisticated credit-card fraud ring that funnels account data to Pakistan from hundreds…
• 10 Forces Guiding the Future of Scripting
  snydeq writes "InfoWorld examines the platforms and passions underlying today's popular dynamic languages, and though JavaScript, Perl, PHP, Python, Ruby, Groovy, and other scripting tools are fast achieving…
• Joost relaunching TV site as online shows abound
  AP - Forget about the boob tube. Places to watch TV on the Internet are proliferating, from NBC Universal and News Corp.'s Hulu to Joost — a site that plans to relaunch Tuesday to make it a more interactive…
• Free US wireless network a step closer
  AFP - A free nationwide wireless Internet network has moved one step closer to becoming a reality in the United States following a key finding by the US Federal Communications Commission (FCC).
• Microsoft Woos Developers Under the Silverlight
  CWmike writes to tell us that with the impending release of their Silverlight 2.0 product, Microsoft is poised to enact the next phase of their plan, wooing developers and designers directly. Microsoft…
• UK university holds artificial intelligence test
  AP - Computers argued, cracked jokes and parried trick questions, all part of an annual test of artificial intelligence carried out at the University of Reading.
• Yahoo Hacker 'Mafiaboy' Eight Years On
  An anonymous reader writes "Eight years ago Mafiaboy (Michael Calce) knocked Yahoo offline. Today he he works as a legitimate security consultant and has just published a book documenting his criminal…
• FCC Green-Lights Wireless Free Internet
  NewsFactor - The Federal Communications Commission has released an engineering report that opens the door for the FCC to apportion a chunk of wireless spectrum for free Internet services across the nation.
• Windows 7 To Dial Down UAC
  Barence writes "Engineers working on Windows 7 have admitted Vista's User Account Control was too intrusive, and are promising to tone it down in the forthcoming Windows 7. 'We've heard loud and clear…
• EU warns youth: turn your MP3 players down!
  Reuters - Millions of youngsters across Europe could suffer permanent hearing loss after five years if they listen to MP3 players at too high a volume for more than five hours a week, EU scientists warned…
• MySpace gives little guys online ad muscle
  AFP - MySpace on Monday unleashed a tool to let small operators with tight budgets easily target online advertising to preferred demographics on the world's leading social networking website.
• New York Times Says Thin Clients Are Making a Comeback
  One of the seemingly eternal questions in managing personal computers within organizations is whether to centralize computing power (making it easy to upgrade or secure The One True Computer, and its data),…
• Is the era of easy credit over for the long haul?
  AP - An inflatable gorilla beckoned from the roof of Don Brown Chevrolet in St. Louis, servers doled out free bowls of pasta and a salesman urged potential customers to "come on up under the canopy and…
• Elcomsoft Claims WPA/WPA2 Cracking Breakthrough
  secmartin writes "Russian security firm Elcomsoft has released software that uses Nvidia GPUs to speed up the cracking of WPA and WPA2 keys by a factor of 100. Since the software allows them to network…
• Microsoft Quietly Previews PC Advisor Repair Tool
  notthatwillsmith writes "On Friday, Microsoft invited members of the Windows Feedback Program to try out a preview of a new application, the Microsoft PC Advisor. The new tool promises to 'continuously…
• New 'Xbox Experience' Too Much For Some 360s
  PC Magazine - There's a lot to look forward to in the upcoming New Xbox Experience -- set to launch on November 19 -- but for those who own Xbox 360s without a hard drive or a 256MB memory card, you may…
• US video game guru heads for space as tourist
  AFP - American millionaire video game guru Richard Garriott followed in his astronaut father's footsteps Sunday, blasting off aboard a Russian rocket to become the world's sixth space tourist.
• Kenya's elephants send text messages to rangers
  AP - The text message from the elephant flashed across Richard Lesowapir's screen: Kimani was heading for neighboring farms.
• Loebner Talks AI
  Mighty Squirrel writes "This is a fascinating interivew with Hugh Loebner, the academic who has arguably done more to promote the development of artifical intelligence than anyone else. He founded the…